• Mon, Oct 22 - 1:45 pm ET

The Tricky Politics Of Hand-Me-Down Children’s Clothes

hand-me-downsI was the youngest of seven cousins. I know a little something about hand-me-down clothes. As a child, there were times when I had 10 different pairs of jeans that were all two inches short at the ankles and one inch wide at the waist. (I was the stickiest stick-girl to ever live.) I knew what it was like to receive an aunt’s favorite shirt that I thought was hideous and try to grin politely before “losing it” in my closet. Before I had kids, I thought I knew all about hand-me-downs and the issues that go with them. Then I had a baby. I quickly learned that the politics of gently-used clothes goes far beyond fashion and fit.

Suddenly, I was thrust into the world of who gets clothing from whom, what you save for yourself, and the ever-present question of payment. Let me tell you, it’s all a little overwhelming. I had no preparation when my daughter started outgrowing her newborn clothing approximately three weeks after she came home. Then a friend of a friend was having a girl and I was suddenly forced to talk to an eager soon-to-be mom who thought my infant’s wardrobe was just ripe for the picking.

Well I decided to put together a few of the key things moms should consider before they open themselves up to the world of hand-me-downs. Before you give or accept, think long and hard about the type of commitment you’re making. Of course, there are all types of hand-me-downs, from toys to furniture, but I’m going to focus on clothes because it seems to be the most thriving trade market among new moms. So here are the basics

To give or not to give. It’s the single largest question. Are you ready to say goodbye to your little one’s clothes? Some people immediately throw their out-grown clothes in tubs and send them off to sisters and friends and long-lost relatives who happen to have a child exactly a year younger than their’s. Others want to hang on to those clothes, cherish them. Personally, I save a handful of my favorites from each size and then start the supply chain to a good friend of mine. I could save them for future kids, but I love buying baby clothes and don’t want to deny myself that excitement should we be lucky enough to have another child.

Obviously, if you’re considering having more kids, you’ll probably want to hang on to the majority of your clothes. They might be useful again a couple years from now. There will be detractors who say, “You’ll probably have the opposite sex and they’ll probably be born during an opposite season.” Blah blah blah. Don’t let someone guilt you into gifting away clothes you paid for. My sister waited until she had her second child before she opened the floodgates of gifting. It made sense to hang on to all those adorable and well-preserved little clothes she worked so hard to keep tidy.

There is one warning I want to send out. Once you’ve decided to start donating those clothes to friends and family, it’s hard to stop. People except that every season, they’ll have a load of new-to-them clothes for their child to choose from. Breaking the cycle takes even more politicking than just refusing to begin anything at all.

(Photo: urfin/Shutterstock)

Share This Post:
  • ipsedixit010

    We went through this years before our son was a glimmer in our eyes. My SIL has two kids who are the youngest of 7 cousins on their dad’s side. 4 years before we even considered children, we received no less that 15 bags worth of boys and girls clothes. They were literally dropped off at our house when we weren’t home. Of the bags, maybe half were without stains or tears and acceptable to wear (after going through 7 kids), some were out of style (or would be by the time our kid was born), and most were just not my taste. Plus, I knew that not only would I be buying new clothes, but both grandmas and aunts are insane present givers. Any future kid of ours would not want for clothing.

    We ended up keeping maybe 1 bag worth of clothes. I asked SIL if she wanted them back and they told us it was “our problem” now. We don’t do garage sales, so we donated them to goodwill. SIL was NOT happy since she could’ve sold them at a garage sale for $.

    Of course, the only things I really wanted for sentimental reasons – my Husband’s “vintage” shirts he wore when he was young – MIL gave to SIL and SIL kept for her future grandsons. : /

    • MommyK

      Wow! Way for them to put the pressure on you guys to have a baby!

    • ipsedixit010

      I’m not sure if it was as much putting pressure on us to have a baby as it was SIL didn’t want the stuff in her house anymore and we were a few streets closer than Goodwill. :) But the dropping it off and leaving it on the porch was pretty classic. Oh, just what we wanted! All your multiple-child used clothes for a kid that doesn’t exist yet! Can’t wait to take up the attic space with this!

      Apparently she was “saving” stuff for us for years, even though we didn’t ask (or want) her to. Luckily, Husband is fabulous (and a huge germaphobe) and put his foot down. No more drive-by hand-me-down deliveries!

    • workingMOM

      hahahah drive-by-hand-me-down deliveries! i love it!
      i got a bunch of hand-me-downs from my SIL (which are in great condition and gorgeous clothes), but another bunch from a cousin, whose daughters are well above-average (i.e. when they were 3 months, they were wearing 12-18 month old clothes). as a result, the clothing is stretched so much that my child (in the 10th percentile of weight), will never, ever be able to wear them.
      i’m giving them to goodwill as it’s been made pretty clear to me (verbally and the fact that they’ve been shoved into big black garbage bags) that they don’t want them back. if i could make $ off of them, i would, but i’d give my cousin a portion – it’s only polite – but i doubt i’ll be garage sale-ing anytime soon.

    • Sl Melodrama

      Ugh…I find this pretty insulting that they would drop off stuff that they just wanted to get rid off. Why not simply give to charity? Or couldn’t they be bothered to make that small effort?

    • Lori B.

      This reminds me of my SIL, although she was a bit more considerate. She has 2 boys (7 and 3). I currently have a daughter, but she offered us her sons’ clothes in case we have a boy one day. Of course I accepted. She was considerate enough to allow me to pick them up from her house on my own terms. What I did not realize was that I was picking up 5 bags of clothes! Now about twice per year she tells me about the clothes she has for me! I can’t say no! Don’t get me wrong, I appreciate the gesture, but it is alot of work un packing the clothes, then putting them in totes in the attic! Not to mention, I probably spent more money in totes than I would have on baby clothes:/ I joke that my attic is insulated in baby clothes!:) I am due with my second child in April, which would be the right season for all of the boys’ clothes and for my daughter’s hand-me-downs. We shall see which sets stay and which sets go!

  • TheLily

    I was the youngest in my direct family. I got hand-me-downs from them. All three of my brothers. I was the oldest of the girls in my biological father’s family, the only girl in my adoptive father’s family. My adoptive mother’s family was all too far away.

    Even the clothes from my bothers only fit because they were 6, 9 and 12 years older then me. They were all thin where as I was and still am a porker.

    I’m in my mid-twenties and I’m finally getting on the hand-me-down train – from my old boss as she sheds pounds. I would have loved to get clothes that weren’t covered in Ninja turtles or perhaps a dress or two.

    All-in-all, I’ll be like my mother. I’ll be spreading my kid’s clothes around once I’m finally done with it. I’ll probably keep it all until I’m certain there won’t be another kid coming, myself. I’d give it to the Salvation Army once we’re done – since that’s where most of my clothes go. Otherwise, a select few will end up in my hope chest, waiting for the next generation of little ones, just like my first dress and my brother’s first onsie. Those are things that will stay, hopefully for a long time in my family, since both are from two generations ago.

  • MommyK

    Oh my, this is a very relavent article for me right now! I have a 10 month old son, and both my sisters are pregnant and live a 9+-hour-drive away. Thank goodness one of them is having a girl, so there isn’t AS MUCH fighting over my stuff. The other sister, M, who already has a 2 yr old girl, doesn’t technically know what sex her baby is, as the drs can’t tell, but she insists up and down that she’s having a boy. M says she’s tight on money, so she asked me months ago in a text message if she can borrow anything my son has outgrown or isn’t using anymore, including clothes.

    I’m waiting firstly to find out if M actually is having a boy, because I’m not digging through my packed-away baby clothes and giving them away if she won’t use them. Secondly, I don’t think I’m ready to part with them yet. He is my first baby, and for me, his clothes have sentimental value. Also, we received a lot of beautiful (and some expensive) new clothes as gifts from our generous family and friends, and I’d like to use them again one day so the gift givers can see the clothes used again. Not to mention the logistics of lending clothes and other baby items over such a far distance. My husband gave me very good advice…..Don’t lend anything that you expect to get back. This will be my approach in dealing with all of this. I know that M expects to pick through my son’s clothes and take what she wants, but I am not so ready to part with it all, and I’ll choose out items for her that I am willing to give, not lend.

    On top of that, with the same sister, M, she insisted before my son was born that we borrow her daughter’s old car seat that she had just outgrown, as well as a swing, and a bassinet. Well, the bassinet broke (luckily not when my son was in it), and now we had to give the car seat and swing back well before my son is outgrown it (he’s a wee one!), since she’s having her baby in December. Now we have to go purchase another one anyways to replace the one we returned to her. If we had known this, we would have politely declined and bought our own in the first place. For our next child, we’re buying anything we need ourselves, rather than borrowing anything at all. The borrowing caused so much headache…never again!

    • katydid

      I cant believe she made you give thsoe things back! I gave a friend pretty much ALL my baby stuff, sold the rest, and then 6 months later….decided to get pregnant. needless to say, there was stuff she was still using that i’d need, but i didnt think it was right to have given her those things and then demand them back because i changed my mind about having a baby. so there was alot of shopping involved this last time around! (we have 3)

    • MommyK

      I gave my other sister, A, my maternity pants, and if I got pregnant right away, I would not be taking them back. Some people!!!

  • Sl Melodrama

    I can’t imagine why anyone would WANT to dress their new baby up in someone else’s kids’ hand me downs :/

    And on the side of the gift giver, it seems so cheap and insulting to give your kids old clothes to a newly born baby, instead of gifting new clothes.

    • Mary Sue

      You sound like a snob. If you don’t want to use hand me downs, that’s fine, but don’t act like anyone who does is gross.

    • rebeccavm

      Seriously. Even if four kids have worn a set of clothes before my 5-month-old grew into them, they still have a lot less wear than most of the clothes in my own closet.

  • MommyK

    I have been on the receiving end of numerous unsolicited hand-me-downs. I haven’t asked anyone for anything, but somehow was pressured into taking home 5 garbage bags full of clothes from a few years ago from one friend (not really in style anymore, and very worn out. Even included socks. I kept 3 or 4 items out of all of it and donated the rest), and a box from another, and a bag of used swim diapers and trunks from a third, none of which we have room to store. I appreciate the thought in a way, but I felt like they just gave these clothes to get them off their hands, or to save themselves a trip to Goodwill. I just end up having to take them to Goodwill myself, because they are so worn, or just not my style, or fits in the wrong season.